How to Compare Two Solar Quotes
Compare two solar quotes on the same scope: cash price, exact equipment, system size, production assumptions, included work, financing, warranties and responsible contractors before choosing.
Published by Home Solar Simplified · Editorial standards
https://homesolarsimplified.org/solar-guides/compare-solar-quotes
Published by Home Solar Simplified. Includes 12 linked sources. Documented editorial date: .
A citation or editorial date does not guarantee a tariff, incentive or program remains unchanged today.
Two solar proposals can show the same number of panels and still offer different system sizes, projected electricity production and total prices. The panel wattage, equipment models, roof layout and financing terms matter more than a headline panel count.
Ask each company for the cash price, total DC capacity in kW, modeled annual production in kWh, equipment and warranty details, and any extra roof or electrical work. Compare those figures side by side before weighing estimated utility savings or monthly payments.
Quick answer: compare the same scope before comparing price
Put both proposals on one worksheet and mark every field included, excluded or unresolved. Compare the same scope: solar-only with solar-only, the same battery and backup scope, the same roof and electrical work, and the cash price before financing.
A lower payment, lower dollars per watt or higher savings estimate does not establish a better proposal until the equipment, production assumptions, responsibilities and contract terms are comparable.
Five Numbers to Request Before Signing for Solar
Use these five numbers as a cover sheet for each written proposal. You can request the documents and review them at home without deciding during a doorstep sales conversation. Then use the detailed checks below to resolve differences between offers.
1. Full installed cash price. Record solar, battery, roof and electrical work separately, before financing and unconfirmed incentives. List exclusions and the conditions that could change the price.
2. Total financing obligation. Record the amount financed, APR, term, down payment, payment schedule and total of payments. Compare the financed price with the cash price. For a lease or PPA, record annual increases and transfer, buyout and early-ending terms instead of treating the agreement as a purchase loan.
3. Expected annual production. Record modeled kWh and the roof, shade and equipment assumptions. Separate electricity used directly at home, stored in a battery and exported. An annual production total alone cannot establish savings.
4. Utility bill expected to remain. Request a monthly illustration of grid purchases, export credits and remaining charges under your actual tariff, plus a less favorable scenario. Do not substitute SCE, PG&E or SDG&E assumptions for LADWP or another utility.
5. Incentives you can substantiate. Identify each program's official source and why the project qualifies. Keep an unapproved benefit separate from your contractual price. For a new 2026 installation, do not automatically subtract the former 30% homeowner credit: IRS deadline FAQ, question 7 explains that advance payment does not preserve the credit when original installation finishes after December 31, 2025. Earlier eligible installations and unused-credit carryforwards are separate questions.
If a quote promises free solar or pressures you to decide immediately, review the FTC's solar consumer warning. Asking for missing numbers is a useful next step; it does not commit you to a purchase.
Identify every company responsible for the project
Write down the legal names of the seller, licensed contractor and any subcontractor, plus who will design, install, interconnect and service the system. Verify the contractor's CSLB license status and classification directly; do not rely on a logo, salesperson badge or marketplace profile.
Ask whether the salesperson is an employee, registered home-improvement salesperson or third party, and which business is named in the installation contract. If the proposal and contract name different companies, require a written explanation before comparing service promises.
Compare exact equipment and system capacity
Record the exact equipment models—not only brand names—for panels, inverters, optimizers, racking, monitoring and any battery or gateway. Compare panel count, watts per module, DC system size, inverter AC rating and the DC-to-AC ratio. Ten panels do not define capacity when module wattage differs.
For California projects, the CEC equipment lists can help confirm listed model information, but CEC says manufacturer-submitted data are not independently confirmed and listing is not a warranty of safety, performance or durability. Use the product data sheet and written warranty too.
Normalize production and utility assumptions
Compare estimated annual production in kWh, monthly production, shade, orientation, tilt, system losses and degradation using the same weather and site inputs. NREL PVWatts can provide an independent estimate for a grid-connected PV system, but it is not a guarantee.
Require each savings model to name the utility tariff, fixed charges, import prices, export compensation, time-of-use periods, expected self-consumption and future-load assumptions. Ask for a lower-production scenario and a lower-export-value scenario. LADWP and California investor-owned utility billing rules are not interchangeable.
Reconcile price, scope and exclusions
Start with the complete cash-installed price and divide only the comparable solar installation amount by DC system watts to calculate dollars per watt. Keep roof replacement, service upgrades, trenching and batteries as visible line items instead of hiding unrelated work inside the ratio.
Check permitting, utility applications, engineering, taxes, monitoring, main-panel work, structural work, roof penetrations, cleanup, commissioning and later panel removal for roof repairs. Mark each field included, separately priced, allowance-based, excluded or unresolved.
Separate solar-only and battery prices
Request separate solar-only and battery prices even when the installer sells one package. For storage, compare usable kWh, continuous and surge kW, backed-up circuits, transfer equipment, reserve, outage recharging, load controls and warranty throughput.
Do not compare a solar-plus-storage total with a solar-only total using one dollars-per-watt figure. Backup capability is an operating design, not a promise created by adding any battery to the proposal.
Compare financing only after the cash scope matches
For each loan, record the cash price, amount financed, APR, term, dealer fees, required prepayment assumption and total of payments. CFPB reported in 2024 that some solar lenders embedded dealer fees above the cash price; that report is a warning to compare written terms, not proof of a fee in a particular offer.
Request payment schedules with and without any assumed tax-credit prepayment. Current IRS guidance says the homeowner Residential Clean Energy Credit is unavailable for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, so a 2026 comparison should not automatically subtract 30%.
Compare warranties, service and performance promises
Separate manufacturer equipment warranties, installer workmanship coverage, roof-penetration coverage and any production guarantee. Record the term, exclusions, transfer rules, labor coverage, shipping or removal costs and claim process for each.
Ask who answers the service call if the seller, installer and equipment manufacturer are different. A long warranty headline is not enough when the responsible business, response time or labor obligation is unclear.
Make the disclosure, proposal and contract agree
For a California residential project, reconcile the proposal with the Solar Energy System Disclosure Document, installation contract and separate financing agreement. CSLB says the disclosure must show total system cost and payments including financing; CPUC guidance says customers must have time to read the current consumer guide before signing where it applies.
Check final equipment, price, total payments, production assumptions, change-order rules, cancellation rights, transfer terms and who receives any incentive. Never treat a possible rebate, tax benefit or verbal promise as a guaranteed price reduction.
Use matched examples to uncover the differences
In a fictional cash comparison, Quote A includes 8 kW DC of solar for $24,000, while Quote B includes 9 kW DC for $28,800. The calculations are $24,000 divided by 8,000 W, or $3.00/W, and $28,800 divided by 9,000 W, or $3.20/W. These invented prices illustrate the calculation; they are not local market benchmarks or advertised offers. If B includes an electrical upgrade that A excludes, obtain the missing cost before treating A as less expensive for equivalent work.
Now imagine two fictional 8 kW proposals predict 11,200 and 12,800 kWh annually. Their modeled yields are 1,400 and 1,600 kWh per installed DC kW. That calculation reveals a difference worth investigating; it does not identify the more accurate proposal. Ask whether the gap comes from roof orientation, shading, equipment, loss assumptions or different weather inputs. Request a comparison using consistent inputs where the designs allow it.
A financing check answers a different question. A fictional $2,000 down payment plus 240 monthly payments of $180 totals $45,200 in scheduled payments. Compare that total with the written cash price, recognizing that the payments occur over time. Confirm that no later payment increase or additional obligation is missing. Do not add a dealer fee again if it is already included in the financed balance.
Give both bidders the same household brief
Gather a full year of utility usage in kilowatt-hours and note any vacancy, unusual air-conditioning use or renovation that affected it. Put planned loads in a separate scenario: current household use first, then a future case with an electric vehicle or other addition. This avoids comparing a design for today's household with another built around an unconfirmed future load.
Send each installer the same short request for revisions and highlight the discrepancies that affect the decision. Ask why one design uses another roof plane, what starting charge and household loads support a battery-runtime estimate, or how a proposed roof repair changes the total. Keep those answers with the proposal version they explain, so a later equipment substitution or price change does not silently invalidate the comparison.
Use a decision rule that allows a pause
Choose only after both proposals use comparable scope and every material difference is explained in writing. A useful comparison can end with neither quote selected when license status, equipment, exclusions, financing or service responsibility remains unresolved.
Keep copies of the proposal, disclosure, contract, financing documents, production model, warranties and salesperson communications. Pressure to sign before those documents reconcile is a reason to pause, not a reason to hurry.
| Item | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Cash price | $24,000 | $28,800 |
| Solar capacity | 8 kW DC | 9 kW DC |
| Solar price per watt | $3.00 | $3.20 |
| Annual production forecast | 12,000 kWh; verify assumptions | 13,000 kWh; verify assumptions |
| Electrical upgrade | Excluded; price unresolved | Included in this example |
| Roof replacement | Excluded | Excluded |
| Battery / financing | Neither included | Neither included |
| Equipment models and service terms | Obtain written details | Obtain written details |
Frequently asked questions
What should I compare first in two solar quotes?
Start with the same installation scope and each complete cash price. Then compare exact equipment, DC capacity, estimated annual production, included roof and electrical work, utility assumptions, warranties and responsible companies before considering financing.
How do I compare quotes with different system sizes?
Divide each comparable solar cash price by DC system watts for dollars per watt, then compare annual kWh estimates and assumptions. A lower dollars-per-watt result does not prove better value when scope, roof layout or production differs.
Should a solar quote name exact equipment models?
Yes. Request manufacturer and model numbers for panels, inverters, optimizers, batteries, gateways and monitoring equipment, plus a written substitution-approval process. Brand names alone cannot establish specifications or warranty coverage.
How do I verify who will install and service the system?
Identify the seller, licensed contractor and subcontractors by legal name. Verify the California contractor license directly with CSLB and make the contract state who installs, interconnects, services and handles warranty claims.
Should battery cost be separated from solar cost?
Yes. Compare solar-only and battery prices separately, then review usable kWh, power, backed-up circuits, transfer equipment and warranty terms. Do not mix a battery into a solar dollars-per-watt comparison.
How do I compare a cash quote with a solar loan?
First make the equipment and installation scope identical. Then compare cash price, amount financed, APR, dealer or lender fees, term, payment schedule, prepayment assumptions and total of payments.
Can a 2026 quote subtract a 30% federal homeowner tax credit?
No automatic subtraction is justified. Current IRS guidance says the Residential Clean Energy Credit is unavailable for property placed in service after December 31, 2025. Verify individual tax facts independently.
What documents should agree before I sign?
The proposal, California Solar Energy System Disclosure Document, installation contract, production model, warranties and financing agreement should agree on equipment, scope, price, payments, assumptions and responsible parties.
Questions worth asking
- What should I compare first in two solar quotes?
- How do I compare quotes with different system sizes?
- Should a solar quote name exact equipment models?
- How do I verify who will install and service the system?
- Should battery cost be separated from solar cost?
- How do I compare a cash quote with a solar loan?
- Can a 2026 quote subtract a 30% federal homeowner tax credit?
- What documents should agree before I sign?
Related guides
Understand what instant online solar estimates can and cannot confirmEvaluate a solar group-buy offer against independent quotesUnderstand the solar installation priceCompare ownership and payment choicesCheck the contract before signingRecognize financing warning signs in a solar quoteUnderstand the latest solar cost benchmarkChoose installers without relying on rankingsCompare Los Angeles solar companiesStill researching solar?
Search homeowner guides by topic, electric utility, or location.
Sources and further reading
Updated: October 2026. Confirm changing details with the official sources.
These links identify documents and resources used for this guide. Listing a source does not mean it was independently checked today. Utility rates, incentives, product specifications and program availability may change; confirm the latest version and effective date with the source.
U.S. Department of Energy — Choosing a Solar InstallerNREL — PVWatts CalculatorFederal Trade Commission — Solar Power for Your HomeCalifornia Public Utilities Commission — Solar Consumer Protection GuideCalifornia Contractors State License Board — Solar RequirementsCalifornia Energy Commission — Solar Equipment ListsConsumer Financial Protection Bureau — Solar Financing Issue SpotlightIRS — Residential Clean Energy CreditCalifornia Public Utilities Commission — Net Energy Metering and Net BillingLADWP — Solar ProgramsIRS — Home energy credit deadlines, including question 7FTC — Avoid solar and clean-energy scamsStart with a home energy checkup
Organize your usage, home details and goals before comparing proposals.
Try the home energy checkupReady to compare companies?
Explore provider options when you are ready to request quotes.
Explore provider options